User blog comment:Garr9988/New Mission/@comment-24588058-20170722053653/@comment-5782071-20170722054142

I suppose, but I just feel like the Phoenix should be more powerful considering it was able to completely revive Artie after his entire body was utterly obliterated (which, upon thinking about how both he and James claimed to see a kind of afterlife, I wonder why James saw it if he never died). At the very least, I imagine they'd be equal in power.

Oh, and explanation I just thought of as to why James' use killed 5 people is because he wasn't the only one who used it. Ifhe had to use the Phoenix to run in and save his girlfriend, then his girlfriend must have also had to hold the Phoenix to survive (unless James somehow shielded her with his body). Idk how James was holding her when he carried her out, and I don't think they were in a position to hold the Phoenix between each of their hands, but it's all I can think of, and 2 uses would account for the higher death count.