Talk:The Heart of The Ocean/@comment-24509764-20140728192353/@comment-31772644-20181229074859

We're not tearing you down for imagination, we're suggesting improvements so as to better fit the lore that we have collectively established as a group. Yes, artifacts need to have an origin or backstory. No, it does not strickly have to be rooted in fact, but it cannot be nothing.

As is, we don't know if this is the movie prop, or if the side-story from the movie was based on real events and this is the genuine article. BESIDES WHICH, I believe you were banned for exactly this sort of behaviour (i.e. lashing out at criticism) ages ag. We're not afraid to do so again. This IS a fan site, but that doesn't mean you can do what you want.